I havn't had the priviledge of seeing the two coins graded higher, but I doubt that either of them is more attractive. There is so little to detract that I honestly would have not batted an eye-lid if PCGS had graded this coin PR66 CAM. Deep mirrors on both sides, the obverse with an...
Full bright lustre and unusually well-struck. Never in circulation but a little baggy. This and 1872 are among the rarest coins of Saxony in high grade. No one can properly explain why these coins are always so hacked up. Many years ago, together with a colleague, we opened an original...
Way, way above average for these. No corrosion or verdigris, almost no nicks or scratches from circulation, very clean but NOT cleaned! Altogether a premium example of this rare coin.
A really flashy Proof with clear, watery mirrored fields. There are only a very few stray hair-lines behind the head. The planchet shows a couple of tiny areas of natural porosity. I have seen a couple of the higher-graded examples that don't look as nice as this one.
This MUST be THE nicest MS63 around. PCGS can be very stuborn. A beautiful coin with swirling lustre on bright, clean surfaces. So nice that I re-submitted this looking for MS 64+. So now you know how nice this coin REALLY is ....
A killer Proof from the Berlin mint! This coin is about as perfect as the day it left the mint. There is a tiny, natural planchet fault to right of the "3" and a hint of abrasion above "HELLER". I don't care how the Jäger or K/M catalogues value these Proofs, they are as scarce as hen's...
A super Proof from the Hamburg mint! This coin is about as perfect as the day it left the mint. There is a hint of a minute abrasion above the "1" in "19", otherwise this Proof is perfect. Considering the nicely matted details, why PCGS didn't feel this coin worthy of a CAM-grade is...
A really bright, flashy example with sleek, swirling lustre. Fresh back from the March Grading Week in Paris, but there is so little wrong with this coin that I am tempted to try for "66".
These coins are by no means rare as Proofs ..... BUT ..... the open fields on the obverse seem to be a magnet for impairment. This example has only few barely visible stray hair-lines which disappear under a rich golden-brown toning with hints of turquoise. The striking is razor-sharp,...
I would have bet my last dollar that this coin would get a "+". I probably will re-submit it in the Autumn. Brilliant swirling lustre with faint hues of blueish grey near the edges around the portrait, the Eagle floats on a sea of silvery brilliance. I can't complain about the MS64...
- 1 of 36